logo

Monday, December 6, 2010

Bernanke On 60 Minutes

I remember when I was a kid, on Sunday nights the family would have dinner and watch 60 minutes. It was the only time we would watch TV at dinner. Back then, 60 minutes was "it." I don't know if it still is or not, but last night Bernanke was on 60 minutes. He seems to be engaging more -- which I think is very good, considering our political discourse is dominated by abject stupidity. I caught the last half of the interview. Here is the interview in its entirety.

November Jobs Report will probably be revised significantly higher

- by New Deal democrat

Take a deep breath. The November jobs report was either an outlier, or at least at the low end of the expected range of error in the trend. That's probably why the stock market shrugged it off on Friday. The odds are very good that it will be revised significantly higher in the next two months. Regardless, since the source of the problem was how to deal with seasonal retail hiring, the best view is to average the October and November reports together. That means even without upward revisions the economy added ~105,000 jobs a month in the last two months - and it is likely to look better within 60 days.

First of all, let's put this in perspective. Even though Friday's jobs report felt like a kick in the gut, at this time last year we were dealing with relentless job losses. November 2009 job losses had just preliminarily been reported as -11,000, and that was over 100,000 better than the next least-worst report. By contrast, here are the monthly jobs numbers (in thousands), excluding census, for 2010:

MonthJob gains
Jan+5
Feb+23
Mar+160
Apr+147
May+21
Jun+50
Jul+77
Aug+113
Sep+53
Oct+172(p)
Nov+39(p)

Every single 2010 jobs number has been positive. No, it's not enough to overcome population growth, which would require about 150,000 a month. Nor is it enough to really begin undoing the job losses of the Great Recession, which would probably require at least 300,000 a month. But excepting the summer slowdown, we have been moving in the right direction for a long time.

Secondly, we have been here before. Here is something Bonddad wrote after September 2009 had just been reported as showing -263,000 jobs lost, another "feel like I've been kicked in the gut" report:
this is a clear step in the wrong direction. Considering the rate of job losses at the beginning of the year (600,000+/month) expecting an immaculate recovery is highly unrealistic. However, the bleeding has to stop at some point. So by the end of this year we have to be far lower than today's number for a recovery to be viable. Consumers cannot continue to hear news like this and expect to have a positive attitude about the economy. It's that simple.
Two months later, that had been revised to -139,000, and November would ultimately be revised to +4,000, the first positive jobs report after the bottom of the Great Recession.

Keep that thought in mind and consider the following: here is the change between initial and final jobs report for each month so far this year, with the net change (including census jobs, which have no impact on the result):

MonthInitialFinalnet change
Jan-20+14+34
Feb-36+39+75
Mar+162+208+46
Apr+250+313+63
May+431+432+1
Jun-125-175-50
Jul-131-66+75
Aug-54-1+53
Sep-95-24+71
Oct+151 +172(p)+21(p)
Nov+39

(p)=preliminary revision

Every single initial jobs report in 2010 except one has been revised higher. The median final revision of the Jan-Sep initial reports has been +53,000. All but two of the nine that have been finally revised have increased by at least +46,000. A revision of +53,000 to November would give us +92,000. Even if October is not revised any higher, the average of the two months would be +132,000, the best showing since March-April. If October were also revised up +53,000 from its initial report, that would be +204,000 for a two month average of +148,000 and a three month average of +136,000. In other words, just normal revisions in line with those previously this year would put us very close to the point where we are keeping up with population growth -- but we won't know that for sure for 2 more months.

And it is clear that, if November's report wasn't an outlier, than it was at the very low end of the range of error. Here is the update of the scatter graph of Initial Jobless Claims vs. Nonfarm Payrolls since the March 2009 high in claims:



It is pretty clear that the initial November report comes in at the weakest point of the overall trend range.

Third, we know the source of the shortfall in the November report: retail hiring. Every month the BLS includes spreadsheets breaking out the data in their report. Schedule B breaks out the establishment report by type of job. Here is a screenshot of that portion of the spreadsheet dealing with service jobs:



Look at the lines entitled "retail trade" and "other services." Had both of these been at the same levels as October, that would have added +80,000 jobs to the report! Further, compare November with the last two months, and with November last year. The monthly change in both series is significantly lower, retail dramatically so, than even last year when the economy was losing jobs.

So let's break out "retail sales" and "other services" (the two areas that were responsible for the big change between October and November) and take a closer look:

Here is the breakdown of the ultimate Seasonally Adjusted numbers, and m/m change:

First, here is "Other services:"

MonthJobsmonth/month change
Jan5317+3
Feb5310-7
Mar5321+11
Apr5333+12
May5337+4
Jun5330-7
Jul5352+22
Aug5363+11
Sep5410+17
Oct5402(p) +30(p)
Nov4319(p)-8 (p)

The median month over month gain for Jan-Sep was +11. If Oct and Nov simply followed that, (i.e., +11 and +11), then Oct overestimated by +19, but Nov's ultimate number is on the mark.

Now, here is "Retail trade:"

MonthJobsmonth/month change
Jan14409.1+49.1
Feb14416.2+7.1
Mar14438.9+22.7
Apr14453.3+14.4
May14447.5-5.8
Jun14431.3+16.2
Jul14442.4+11.2
Aug14448.8+6.4
Sep1444,9-3.9
Oct14457.9(p) +13.0(p)
Nov14429.8(p)-28.1(p)

The median month over month gain in retail jobs for Jan-Sep was +7.1 If October and November simply added +7.1 each month, then October is too high by ~6, but November is WAY off. November is too low by ~30!

Another way of looking at this is that, according to the BLS, in November we gave back almost every single retail job we added since February. Further, the last time we gave back 30k or more jobs in one month was in October 2009. Is there anybody who thinks that really happened?


Just to check how big (or not) a role revisions to the "retail trade" number was in the overall revisions, I specifically checked the initial vs. final revised number for that item. Here is the result:

MonthInitialFinalnet change
Jan42.149.1+7.0
Feb-0.4+7.1+7.5
Mar14.922.7+7.8
Apr12.414.4+2.0
May-6.6-5.8+0.8
Jun-6.6-16.2-10.2
Jul6.711.2+4.5
Aug-4.9+6.4+11.3
Sep5.7-3.9-9.6
Oct27.9 13.0-14.9(p)

The median change for the "retail trade" series in the Jan-Sep 2010 revisions is only +4.5 thousand, meaning that if the November initial report missed big on retail positions, while not likely it is at least possible that in addition to a significant upward revision on the order of +50,000 for the other items in the initial November report, there could also be a big positive retail jobs revision .

Fourth, it is adjusting for seasonal retail hiring that is the problem. Retailers hire a lot of temporary help for the holiday season. It is a known factor and so is automatically seasonally adjusted. But the adjustment can create outsized effects. In October, the BLS "expected" employers to hire about 118,800 retail employees. In fact they hired 131,800, so the Seasonally Adjusted number was +13,000. In November, the BLS "expected" employers to hire +328,900 retail employees, but they actually hired +300,800, so the inital Seasonally Adjusted number reported on Friday was -28,100.

This is the logic behind the following graph by Calculated Risk, showing non-seasonally adjusted October through December retail hiring for the past 30 years:



Contrast this with, for example, May, when the BLS "expects" employers to add 101.900 "retail trade" jobs, only about 1/3 of November's adjustment.

In short, relatively minor changes in employment plans at this time of year, because of seasonal adjustments, can have outsized effects. As a result, it is probably best to average October and November's reports, as I have done above, to deal with these effects.

Finally, let's bear in mind that both ADP and TrimTabs called for job gains of between 90,000 and 120,000 in November, and both have been consistently understating the BLS reports this year. A revision more in line with those reports would make sense.

In that regard, I have been favored by Matt Trivisonno with a YoY withholding tax graph from his Daily Jobs Update site, current through last week, which adjusts for the "making work pay" credit of the ARRA. It has been relentlessly improving:



This graph has accurately tracked YoY aggregate hours worked in the past ten years, and is currently showing the same YoY% improvement it did at the end of 2004 -- when the economy was consistently adding 200,000 jobs a month.


Two caveats: On the other hand, a comparison of the Household Report and the Establishment Report, including Friday's numbers, shows that both have leveled off since the census began its layoffs in May. Furthermore, it cannot be denied that the Household Report has shown actual declines in the last two months, which were not affected by the census at all.



In addition to that very significant caution, bear in mind that the BLS has already told us that they are going to reduce the total jobs count for the 12 months between March 2009 and March 2010 by an average of 30,000 a month. This is very much a wild card. On the one hand, the September 2009 report mentioned at the outset of this post, after having been increased to -113,000, was knocked back down to -225,000 by the yearly adjustment announced this past February. On the other hand, the November 2009 report - the one and only positive report - was actually increased by 64,000 jobs in those yearly revisions. The BLS has historically underestimated job losses during recessions, and underestimated job gains in the first part of a recovery, so it is about equally possible that the revisions which will be announced in February 2011 will go either way.

Bottom line: it is likely, but not certain, that the November payrolls report will be revised significantly higher, and that we continue to move in the right direction. The best approach is to average the October and November reports for the truer trend, which even now is +105,000 each month.

FSA Humiliated

Unsurprisingly the FSA's attempt to hide the details of its 18 month "investigation" into the near collapse of RBS, via a pathetic one paragraph "a series of bad decisions was made" fig leaf, has brought down upon it the scorn it so richly deserves.

Sir Fred "the shred" Goodwin is said to be perfectly happy for the report to be published (not that his approval or disapproval needs to be sought), and indeed George Osborne is pushing for the report to be published. RBS is, after all, a public asset.

However, the FSA are defiantly sticking to its guns and refusing to publish until a "legal view" could be established that it could do so within the exemptions of the law.

A nice "excuse" clause such as that may well be appropriate for certain private organisations. However, as noted, RBS is a public asset it is in the public's interest to see the results of the FSA's labours.

Quite why the FSA is so determined to keep the report hidden from public view is causing many people to wonder as to whether it is protecting RBS, or itself and its investigation, from rigorous scrutiny.

Either way the FSA, by this shameful episode, have demonstrated that it has no future.

Sunday, December 5, 2010

Yesterday's Market




Considering the disappointment from of the jobs report, Friday's chart is actually decent. Prices moved sideways for most of the day, consolidating in a rectangle pattern (a). Prices broke out in the late afternoon, trading right on top of important levels (b), before moving higher into the close on increasing volume (c).


On the daily chart, prices are right at important resistance levels (a). Also note the EMA picture is bullish (b). The A/D and CMF confirm that more money is moving into the market right now (c and d) and the MACD has given a bullish buy signal (e).


First, on the IEF chart, notice that prices have continued to run into upside resistance at the EMAs and Fibonacci levels.


Treasury prices gapped higher at the open (a), but fell quickly and sharply. They attempted to rally (b) but the MACD indicated the rally was on weakening momentum (c). Prices continued to move lower throughout the rest of the trading day, hitting resistance at the EMAs.


Treasury prices continue to move lower (a) with the EMAs printing a very bearish picture. Also note that money is flowing out of the market (b and c) and momentum is clearly bearish (d).


After breaking the upside trend (a) and moving lower for two days (b), the dollar gapped lower on Friday (c).



Prices hit upside resistance at the 200 day EMA (a) and have since moved lower (a). Prices are now finding support at the 50 day EMA (b). Note the A/D line has printed lower (c) and the CMF is also showing money moving out of the market. Also note the MACD is also about to print a sell signal (e).

Friday, December 3, 2010

Weekend Weimar and Beagle

It's that time of the week .... we'll be back on Monday


Mr$. Bonddad and I were out of town last week, so we had friends watch the house. We left a 12-pack for our nephew, which Sarge knocked off the kitchen island. However -- he sacrificed his paw for the beer. Anything for the beer. He's fine now.




Weekly Indicators: New Deal democrat smackdown Edition

- by New Deal democrat

On Wednesday, some commenter named "New Deal democrat" took up Prof. Brad Delong on a bet at his blog. Prof. Delong said, based on the ADP report, that less than 130,000 jobs would be added in November. This eeedjyut NDD threw a dart and predicted +190,000. So, this week's big number had to be the very disappointing +39,000 jobs report this morning. U-3 unemployment went back up to 9.8%. The average workweek declined -0.1 hours. Overtime was flat. The manufacturing workweek, one of the ten LEI, was also flat.

In addition to 11,000 workers laid off in government, there were another 15,000 laid off in manufacturing, and 28,100 lost in retail. Government losses, alas, were expected. Manufacturing losses are probably the coincident fruits of the decline in the manufacturing component of the LEI over the summer.

All was not bleak. YoY hourly earnings were up 1.6%. Aggregate hours worked increased 0.1%. Much more importantly, both September's and October's numbers were revised higher - a pattern that has persisted now for 11 of the last 12 months. September's original report of -95,000 including census losses has been revised upward +71,000 in the last two months to -24,000. October's good report was also revised up to +172,000. Last month, the final revisions to August turned that report, which also included census losses, from -54,000 to -1,000, a gain of +53,000.

Since the NFP report today seems to contradict the flood of good new reports we've seen in the last months, why do I suspect that in two months' time this report will look substantially different? I may yet have my revenge on Prof. Delong!

(Seriously, I do expect that this report will be revised substantially upward. More Monday.)

Now let's take a look at this week's high frequency data:

Gas at the pump declined two more cents to $2.86 a gallon. This is about $0.15 above its average from a few months ago. A barrel of Oil increased to $86 this week. Gasoline usage reamins lower than last year, 8.867 B gallons vs. 8.943 B a year ago. Gasoline stocks are still back into their normal range for this time of year. Over the longer term, gasoline usage still remains about 5% below its rate from the first half of the past decade.

The Mortgage Bankers' Association reported that its seasonally adjusted Purchase Index increased 1.1% last week, rising to a another post-April high, and for the first time in ages actually exceeed its level of a year ago, by 2.7%. Meanwhile, the Refinance Index came to an abrupt halt, decreasing 21.6% from a week ago, showing the dramatic effect of increased mortgage rates (to which this index is, not surrisingly, very sensitive).

The BLS reported 436,000 new claims. The 4 week moving average fell to 431,000. Five of the last six weeks have shown 440,000 or fewer new claims. It certainly appears that we are moving into a lower range.

The ICSC reported same store sales for the week ending November 27 increased 3.5% YoY, the best showing in several months, and were also up 0.5% week over week. Shoppertrak reported that "Black Friday weekend" sales were flat compared with last year.

Railfax for the fourth week in a row showed a slight decline in the advance over last year's loads for all sectors. Motor vehicles and housing materials remained slightly ahead of last year's rate. I understand that retailers ordered holiday shipments early this year, because of bottlenecks and delayed shipping last year, so a word of caution about over-interpreting the recent relative decline.

The American Staffing Association reported for the week ending November 20 another increase to 101.0. This metric now exceeds every other year for the same week except 2007. In the next few weeks this index will decline substantially, but the question will be how far in comparison with last year.

M1 was up 1% for the week, up 2.3% vs. last month, and +8% YoY, meaning "real M1" is up 6.8%. M2 was up less than 0.1%for the week, 0.4% vs. last month, and 3.2% YoY, meaning "real M2" is up 2.0%. Real M2 is not going down, but it is making very little progress towards breaking out of the "red zone" below +2.5% YoY.

Weekly BAA commercial bond rates decreased 0.08% last week back to 5.95%. This compares with yields on 10 year bond yields down-.05%. This does not indicate any stress on corporate bonds.

The Daily Treasury Statement showed that this year set a new record for November tax recesipts, at $138.9 B in receipts vs. $127.7 B a year ago, a gain of 11.2 B or 8.9% (but bear in mind there was one more reporting day this year than last. Nevertheless, this November's pace set a new record for the month, 2.0% above the previous record from November 2007 (which is less than the 4.6% inflation since then). Since the real, seasonally adjusted bottom in tax receipts took place no later than October 2009, this also marks the first advance over an increasing absolute number from a year before.

Finally ... my post yesterday about DK certainly hit a nerve, as there have been over 20 comments. If you haven't, I encourage you to read them all. One of the reasons I added the "recent comments" section at the right is so that commenters could continue to discuss something after it has scrolled out of view, so feel free to do so. Obviously, you are not alone. And to those who said that after Bonddad left, there was no more decent discussion of the economy on DK ... errmmm, {{clearing throat}}... personally, I feel insulted. But have a nice weekend!

More Thoughts on the Employment Report



First, consider this chart:


The last six months have been extremely disappointing from an employment perspective. While we saw nice increases before that time, since then total establishment job growth has been fluctuating right around 0. Last month we printed over 150,000, and this month we saw a mere 39,000 -- a clear deceleration.

This is especially concerning considering the improvement we've seen over the last month. As I've been noting all week, and as reported in the latest Beige Book -- the last month we've seen a good improvement across the board in a variety of economic sectors.

The question is why the slowdown?

Here are some thoughts, in no particular order of importance.

1.) We've only recently seen a pick-up in economic activity and numbers. The previous Beige Book indicated the economy was weakening. In other words, there hasn't been enough improvement, especially in light of the slowdown we saw over the summer as a result of the EU situation.

2.) Companies are printing strong profit numbers without new hiring; from their perspective, there is no need for new employees.

3.) There isn't enough domestic growth (US based growth) to warrant the new hiring

4.) The legal uncertainty argument: the changes we've seen in the laws are extremely complicated and one (health care) has a direct bearing on hiring decisions. Until companies have sorted out the ramifications of these changes (and as soon as regulations are actually written) then we'll see an increase.

5.) There is still uncertainty about the future; that is, there is still enough concern about future growth prospects to put a freeze on big hiring plans.

6.) We're still seeing enough problems from Europe to raise enough concern about the future.

NFP + 39,000, Unemployment Rate +9.8%

From the BLS:

The unemployment rate edged up to 9.8 percent in November, and nonfarm payroll employment was little changed (+39,000), the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported today. Temporary help services and health care continued to add jobs over the month, while employment fell in retail trade. Employment in most major industries changed little in November.


This is extremely disappointing, especially in light of the ADP employment numbers and the improving situation in the initial jobless claims market.

Let's start with the household survey.

The civilian labor force (the denominator in certain calculations) was essentially unchanged, moving from 153,904 to 154,007. The total employed decreased from 139,061 to 138,888, or a decrease of 173,000 This led to a decrease in the employment/population ratio from 58.3% to 58.2%. The total number of unemployed increased from 14,843 to 15,119, or an increase of 276,000. This lead to the increase in the unemployment rate from 9.6% to 0.8%. So, according to the household survey, there was a decrease in employment and an increase in unemployment over a steady sized population. Basically, this is the worst case scenario for the employment situation.

Let's move to the establishment survey:

Total private hiring increased 50,000. Goods producing industries decreased 15,000 while services increased 65,000. Most of this gain came from professional and business employment, which increased 53,000, while health care and education employment increased 30,000.

Average weekly hours were unchanged at 34.3 hours, but average hourly earnings increase a penny, which in turn increased average weekly earnings.

Again, this report is a big disappointment, especially considering the momentum increase in the employment situation. On a scale of 1 to 10, I'd give this report a 3. Some jobs were created and earnings did increase, but we're still stuck in the barely growing employment situation we were in before.

A note to commenter Bobby: the original post had far to many typos. Thanks for the catch and I will work on that in the future.

Yesterday's Market





Yesterday, the markets opened with a strong rally (a) that eventually changed into a sideways market that consolidated in to rectangles (b and c). As with Wednesday's trading, notice that the MACD spiked in the AM with the rally but then moved lower for the rest of the day. This is a fairly standard development for this indicator on early spike days.



On the daily chart, notice that prices are continuing to move beyond the resistance line (a).



On the daily chart of the IWMs (the Russell 2000), notice that prices have moved through resistance (a) with a strong bar. Also notice the EMA position (a) -- the shorter EMAs are about the longer EMAs, all the EMAs are moving higher and prices are above the EMAs. This is important because the IWMs represent risk capital -- money that is more oriented towards capital gain rather than gain and dividends. As such, this move confirms that upward move of the SPYs.


Also note the transports are printing a chart similar to the IWMs, adding further confirmation to the upward move we're seeing in the equity markets.


The dollar has clearly broken its uptrend (a) and is now moving lower in a downward sloping channel (b). Notice that within the channel there are several strong downward moves (c), indicating selling pressure is fairly strong right now.


On the dollar's daily chart, notice that prices hit resistance at the 200 day EMA (a) but are now moving lower. This lower move coincides with a possible easing of stresses in the EU region, adding fundamental downward pressure on the dollar.

FSA Ridiculed

Unsurprisingly the FSA's pathetic refusal to publish details of its investigation into RBS (which let management off the hook, and only mildly rebuked them by saying that the near collapse of RBS was the result of a series of "bad decisions") has received the scorn that it so rightly deserves.

The Telegraph quotes Lord Oakeshott, a Liberal Democrat Treasury spokesman:

"We cannot learn the lessons of the worst corporate crash in British history if we can't see the evidence."

Lord Oakshott went on to say:

"Most people, taxpayers and City experts alike, simply will not accept there was no failure of corporate governance on the part of the management, board and regulator of RBS."

One wonders if the FSA's reluctance to publish the details of its investigation is designed to save the blushes of the ex board members of RBS, or to save itself and its pathetic report/"findings" from rigorous scrutiny.

Why is the FSA still in existence?

If someone has a copy of the report, I suggest that they leak it to WikiLeaks (currently accessible via this domain http://213.251.145.96)

Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More