logo

Wednesday, February 29, 2012

The case for economic pessimism: exhausted consumers

- by New Deal democrat

Recently most important items of economic data -- housing permits, car sales, new jobless claims, payrolls, consumer confidence, etc. -- have all moved substantially in the right direction. But there is always a bearish case to be made, and the best one, it seems to me, focuses on the consumer.

Here's a graph of real hourly wages (i.e., wages minus the CPI) (blue) and real disposable income (red) for the last year:



As you can see, real wages declined by about 2% since late 2010. Real disposable income also declined beginning last spring and so far has not made up all of the loss.

Primarily but not solely due to gasoline prices, consumers have had to dig into savings accumulated during the "great recession" to continue spending, causing a decline in both savings (blue) and the savings rate (red):



In the past, a spike in inflation has always led to economic weakness - shown in a decline in measures of inflation. Note that in 2001 and 2008, when commodity prices (red) and finished goods prices (green) declined to the same level as consumer prices (blue), we were about midway through the recession:



Even the two cases where commodity prices did not weaken significantly more than consumer prices (2003 and 2006) coincided with brief periods of especially weak GDP growth.

This is consistent with the fact that a number of long leading indicators -- Real M2, housing permits, and bond prices -- bottomed after a period of significant weakness about 12 months ago. Typically that weakness is most manifest in the consumer economy in about 1 year or so -- i.e., now.

In that regard it's worth noting that the most recent proprietary article on ECRI's site is entitled, "Can the US consumer keep spending?" Based on last Friday's round of interviews, obviously they think not.

Barring a reversal of fortune, ECRI is probably right about the US consumer. But note that none of the above graphs are predictive rather than explanatory. In fact real wages and real disposable income have rebounded slightly since autumn, and there is nothing inherent in any of the above graphs indicating that this rebound will not continue.

1954: PCEs




The above chart shows the percentage contribution PCEs made to to GDP for the four quarters of 1954, along with the contribution of various sub-parts of PCEs. Note the incredible strength of PCEs -- consumers are spending a lot of money on an assortment of items.



The above chart is from the Economic Report to the President, 1955.  It simply highlights the incredible growth in a variety of conumer goods that were purchased by consumers during this time.  As the report highlighted:


Also consider the following chart:



 The above chart shows PCEs, income and sales.  Notice that we don't see an increase in disposable personal income until the end of the year.  This is due to the recession which lasted until July 1954.  However, thanks to a well-executed policy to limit the impact of the of the slowdown, the recessions overall effect was mild (from the ERP):





The above chart highlights now consumers continued to purchase a constant amount of durable goods, but expanded their purchases of both services and non-durable goods.

Also helping this process was the consumer finance sector, as noted by the Federal Reserve:







Morning Market Analysis

A few people have noted that they are having trouble viewing images.  Not being the most tech savvy person, I'm not exactly sure why this is happening.  However, over the last few weeks, I've been copying images from various websites and pasting them into the blog as opposed to saving them on my computer and uploading them.  Today, I'm uploading to see if this makes a difference.  Please let me know if you continue to have problems.



Silver has been forming a downward sloping channel over the last 9-10 months.  Prices are now approaching key resistance levels relative to that.  In addition, the MACD -- which negative -- is moving higher.



Yesterday, prices broke through resistance on the daily chart.  Also note the MACD buy signal and the fact that the EMAs are bullishly aligned, with all moving higher.  Finally, yesterday's price action was a nice gap higher with prices printing a strong candle.


The 5-minute silver chart shows prices rallied strongly until about 1PM and then consolidated gains.  The best part of this chart for the bulls is the lack of a sell-off.


The 60 minute silver chart shows strong resistance at the 33.50 level.  Once price moved through that level, they consolidated around the 34.50 area, which they moved through yesterday.


The gold ETF has also rallied, moving through resistance at the 171 area.  Now we see resistance at the 175 level.


The above chart is a reason for the rally in both gold and silver: the dollar is moving lower.  After rallying through the early part of the year in response to the EU crisis, the dollar has moved lower, first hitting support at the 200 day EMA and now moving below that level. 

Happy LTRO Day II

Well my earlier bet on LTRO as being around Euro650BN was wide of the mark!

The ECB's 3 year LTRO has just been announced as being Euro529BN, given to the 800 banks which have come forward with their begging bowls.

Happy LTRO Day

At 10:20GMT today we will know how much money has been borrowed under the ECB's LTRO scheme, which is being used to sandbag banks in the likely event of a sovereign debt default.

The ECB claims that the money will be used to stimulate growth, the reality is that it will be placed by the banks at the ECB to be used when the forthcoming Greek default causes a run on the banks.

For what it is worth, I am taking a non financial punt on LTRO being around Euro650BN.

Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Will Food Prices Derail the Expansion? Part II

In the previous article, I noted that the food component of CPI -- along with various sub-parts of the component -- are at high levels.  In addition, these levels are approaching readings that have preceded previous recession.  Today, I want to look at grains, as these prices are a primary reason for the recent increase in food prices.  Finally, I'll highlight the latest USDA crop forecast which shows an increasing supply of grains is coming, which will hopefully slow the inflationary pressures.

Above is a 25 year chart of wheat.  Notice that for the years 1987 to roughly 2007 (about 20 years), prices traded in a fairly tight range of 2.00/bushel to 5.00/bushel -- with the exception of a price spike in 1996.  However, wheat prices are now in a different trading range.  Before the last recession, we see a huge spike, with prices briefly getting to the $13/bushel area before dropping down.  Then notice how prices spiked to over $8.00/bushel a few years ago.  Now, prices are lower, but they are still above the $5.00 price top associated with the preceding 20 year period.


Corn prices show a similar pattern to wheat prices.  However, their recent, secondary spike hasn't completely abated.  This is due to the corn/ethanol relationship.


The soy chart is a bit between wheat and corn.  First, we see a period of relative price stability for about a 20 year period from 1987 to 2007.  During this time,  we see a trading range of between $4.00 and $9.00.  Then we see a massive spike preceding the last recession, a sell-off due to the recession and then a rise as the world's economies started back up.  Prices have fallen from the recent increases, but they are still at high historical levels.

I've included rice because this is a base food element for SE Asia.  Notice how this chart most closely resembles the charts associated with soy beans above.]

However, let's take a look at the last year's worth of pricing information from the grains markets.



Soybeans dropped sharply last fall, but have since rebounded.  They are approaching the $13.00 level, which provided the floor for prices over the last summer.



Corn prices have also fallen from their spike last year, and are currently trading at a subdued price level.



Wheat prices have seen the most dramatic decrease.  

The big reason for longer term price spikes is the increase in food demand from growing regions.  Consider the following chart from the latest USDA long-term projections estimate:



Notice how over the last 10 years, Africa and the Middle East have been importing and increasingly large amount of course grains (corn)




Wheat imports have seen an increase over the last 10 years and are projected to see further increases over the next 10.



Global rice imports have seen a tremendous amount of increase over the last 10 years, and are expected to see an even large increase over the next 10.  However, it's not all due to Asian imports, as sub-Saharan Africa is also a big net importer.




Soybean imports have increased greatly over the last 10 years, largely due to China.  As their economy grows -- and as their population sees it's standard of living increase -- we can expect to see this increase continue.

All the above charts have one, common pattern.  World food demand is increasing, thereby putting continued, upward pressure on prices.  What's also important to remember and note is the vast majority of demand is occurring in the developing world -- markets such as China, Brazil, India, Russia an Africa are seeing an increase in overall demand.

To conclude:

1.) The year price charts of various agricultural prices show a decrease in inflationary pressures.  This should help to lower food price pressures for the next 6-12 months.  However

2.) World economies outside the US are growing a t very strong rates, placing increased demand pressures on food prices.  In short, don't expect the lull to last.  In addition, we're only one natural disaster or strange weather incident away from price spikes.


Share

Twitter Delicious Facebook Digg Stumbleupon Favorites More